Upper East Side
Hours & Location
1426 3rd Ave,
New York, NY 10028
(917) 599-9594
uppereastside@emmysquaredpizza.com
Monday - Thursday: 11AM-10PM
Friday + Saturday: 11AM-11PM
Sunday: 11AM-10PM
Praised by reviewers as "must try" and "a welcome addition" to Manhattan’s vast pizza scene, Emmy Squared Pizza introduced our one-of-a-kind fare to the Upper East Side in December 2019. Founded on an unconditional love of well-made food, Emmy Squared combined a New York-style "grandma" pie with a Detroit-style pizza, and then topped it off with an added dose of culinary creativity. But we didn’t stop at our pizza – Emmy’s Le Big Matt Burger has been recognized as one of "The Best New Burgers in NYC" (Gothamist) and one of the "20 Best Burgers in NYC" (Infatuation). Besides award-winning pizzas and burgers, you’ll find delectable appetizers, sandwiches, and salads on our extensive menu. We look forward to welcoming you to Emmy Squared Upper East Side and sharing our unique take on American "comfort food."
Menus
Tiers of Cheers Happy Hour!
Available Monday - Friday | 3PM-6PM
-
Select Beer
$5 -
House Wine
$7 -
Well Cocktails
$9Nothing shaken, nothing stirred
For The Table
-
Sriracha Glazed Chicken Wings
$13.90Boneless or Bone-In | Crispy, hand-breaded boneless bites, sriracha crystal glaze with peanuts and cilantro, or served naked
-
Cheesy Garlic Sticks
$13.90Six crispy garlic breadsticks tossed in roasted garlic and pesto. Served with our red sauce
-
Zia Fries
Seasoned waffle fries, bacon, scallions, hatch chile cheddar queso, green ranch
$16.75
Make it a regular portion $9.95
-
BKLYN Mozz Sticks
$15.80Five large, crispy, hand-stretched, mozzarella sticks served with our signature house-made red sauce
Salads
-
Caesar Salad
Chopped romaine, anchovy Caesar dressing, pecorino, and sprizolina
Regular $10.90
Shareable $14.50
add crispy chicken $5
add grilled chicken $5
-
Shaved Brussels Sprouts Salad
Pickled red onion, cashew, blue cheese, dried cherries, miso dressing
Regular $12.50
Shareable $16.80
add crispy chicken $5
add grilled chicken $5
-
Chopped Wedge Salad
Chopped romaine lettuce, Bacon, olives, cherry tomatoes, celery, ‘Bama white sauce
Regular $11.90
Shareable $15.90
Burgers + Sandwiches
served on pretzel bun with pickle on the side add WAFFLE FRIES | 8-
Le Big Matt Burger
1/2 lb double-stacked grass-fed beef, American cheese, Sammy sauce, greens & pickles, on a toasted pretzel bun with waffle fries
$28
Make It a Single-Stack $25
add bacon $3
-
Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Crispy breaded chicken, pickles, greens, radish, green ranch on a pretzel bun
Single-Stack $14.90
Double-Stack $17.90
-
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Crispy breaded chicken, red sauce, mozzarella, basil on a pretzel bun
Single-Stack $14.90
Double-Stack $17.90
Create Your Own Detroit-Style Pizza
SIXER [8x10 | 6 slices] 18.80 | TENNER [10x14 | 10 slices] 25.50 vegan cheese + gluten-free crust available on SIXER PIZZAS upon request +4-
Toppers
Sixer $2.50
Tenner $3.50
caramelized onion
Green Olives
pickled jalapeños
banana pepper
bell pepper
mushroom
pineapple
red onion
basil
hot honey
Pineapple Chili Glaze
Pepperoni
Italian Sausage
Shaved Sirloin
Bacon
Crispy Chicken
Nashville Hot Chicken
Ricotta
Smoked Gouda
Calabrian Chilies
Pizza
-
Classic
Red sauce, cheese blend
Sixer $18.80
tenner $26.50
-
The Founders
(Formerly known as something else. Then the lawyers called) Red sauce, cheese blend, house-pickled jalapeños, Ezzo Pepperoni, and honey
Sixer $24.80
Tenner $32.50
-
RONI SUPREME
Red sauce, cheese blend, Ezzo pepperoni, and spicy Calabrian chilis
Sixer $24.80
Tenner $33.50
-
Margherita
Red sauce, cheese blend, burrata, basil
Sixer $24.80
Tenner $33.50
-
Vodka
Vodka sauce, cheese blend, basil, pecorino
Sixer $25.80
Tenner $26.50
-
MVP
Vodka sauce, red sauce, parsley pesto, cheese blend, sesame seed crust
Sixer $20.80
Tenner $29.50
Make it a VIP | add ezzo pepperoni & Calabrian chile $5
-
VIP
Vodka sauce, red sauce, parsley pesto, cheese blend, Ezzo Pepperoni, Calabrian chilies, sesame seed crust
Sixer $25.80
Tenner $34.50
-
Big Ang
Vodka sauce, cheese blend, ricotta, double pecorino, Italian sausage, banana peppers
Sixer $25.80
Tenner $33.50
-
Big HAWAIIAN
Cheese blend, Ezzo Pepperoni, bacon, pineapple, pineapple chili glaze
Sixer $25.80
Tenner $33.50
-
Good Paulie
Cheese blend, caramelized onions, Italian sausage, smoked gouda
Sixer $23.80
Tenner $31.50
-
Miranda
Four cheese combination of Emmy’s cheese blend, smoked gouda, pecorino, ricotta, bacon, hot honey
Sixer $20.80
Tenner $28.50
-
DELUXE
Red sauce, cheese blend, bell peppers, mushrooms, crumbled Italian sausage
Sixer $20.80
Tenner $28.50
-
The Quinn
Four cheese combination of Emmy’s cheese blend, smoked gouda, pecorino, ricotta
Sixer $18.80
Tenner $26.50
-
Nashville Hot Chicken
Nashville hot chicken, ‘Bama white sauce, chopped pickles
Sixer $20.80
Tenner $28.50
-
ANGEL
Ricotta, truffle cream, mushrooms, parsley pesto
Sixer $23.80
Tenner $32.50
Something Sweet
-
Skillet Baked Brownie
$10warm triple chocolate baked brownie topped with vanilla ice cream and maldon salt
Drinks
COCKTAILS
Try a SHORTY! All the drink, half the pour.-
RHUBY SOHO
New Amsterdam Gin, Aperol, rhubarb bitters, lemon
regular
shorty
-
L’IL FASHIONED
Cognac, Lillet Blanc, orange bitters, Angostura bitters, honey syrup (not available as a Shorty)
-
SKINNY MARGARITA
Lunazul Tequila Blanco, agave, lime
regular
shorty
-
EMOTIONAL DAMAGE
Lunazul Tequila Blanco, lime, passionfruit syrup
regular
shorty
-
ESPRESSO YOURSELF
New Amsterdam Vodka, Borghetti Espresso Liqueur, Spirits of Alchemyʻs Velvet Mood Mixer
regular
shorty
-
TROPIC LIKE IT’S HOT
Vida Mezcal, pineapple chunks, basil, lime, simple syrup, club soda
regular
shorty
Mocktails
-
LAVENDER 75
Lavender syrup, lemon juice, club soda
-
PINEAPPLE THE BASIL
Pineapple chunks, basil, lime, simple syrup, club soda
-
EMOTIONAL SUPPORT
Passionfruit syrup, lime juice, ginger beer
Kiddos
-
BUBBLE GUM SODA
-
BLUE RASPBERRY LEMONADE
Wine
-
Sparkling
-
Prosecco, Benvolio, Prosecco DOC
glass
bottle
-
Whites
-
Pinot Grigio, Benvolio, Fruili DOC
glass
bottle
-
Chardonnay, Carmel Road, Monterey
glass
bottle
-
Riesling, Kendall-Jackson, Monterey
glass
bottle
-
Sauvignon Blanc, Crowded House, Marlborough, NZ
glass
bottle
-
Rose
-
Rosé of Pinot Noir, La Crema, Monterey
glass
bottle
-
Reds
-
Pinot Noir, Carmel Road, Monterey
glass
bottle
-
Zinfandel, Edmeades, Mendocino
glass
bottle
-
Cabernet Sauvignon, Carmel Road, California
glass
bottle
-
Chianti, Tenuta di Arceno, Chianti Classico
glass
bottle
Beer
-
Narragansett
-
Dogfish Head 60 Minute IPA
-
Corona Extra
-
Blue Moon
-
Brooklyn Brown Ale
-
Coney Island Pilsner
-
Sloop Juice Bomb IPA
-
Blue Point Toasted Lager
-
Sloop Juice Bomb IPA
-
Downeast Cider
-
Athletic Upside Dawn Golden Ale N/A
Kids
for kiddos 8 and under-
Pizza Sticks
$10fries + small drink
-
Chicken Bites
$10fries + small drink
-
Burger
$10fries + small drink
-
substitute fries for corn, carrots or pineapple
-
Dessert
$3scoop of vanilla ice cream
Upper East Side
Open Dining Room: 20
Semi-Private Outdoor: 25
Full Buyout Capacity: 85
Full Buyout Pricing: Pricing available upon request